When small property disputes come up, neighbors usually work things out and life moves on. But sometimes the disagreement ends with a building cut in half. That’s what happened in Dover-Foxcroft, Maine, where a man who complained about a property line ended up losing half his garage to a reciprocating saw.
A Property Line Challenge That Backfired
The Brawn family moved into a house in 2012 where Mr. Brawn had grown up. The property originally included about a quarter-acre to the south, but that piece had been sold off and a small home was built there.
Things stayed calm until 2016, when the owner of that smaller property died. His wife inherited it and rented it out to others.
According to the outlet, relations grew tense with the people who rented or visited the property. In April, the family spread wood chips in the backyard so a tractor could get down the slope to clear fallen tree limbs.
That’s when the former owner’s son stuck a stake in the ground and told them to get their stuff off the land.
They hired a land surveyor to check. It turned out the man was wrong — wrong by eight or ten feet, which matters on a small lot. The real boundary line ran straight through the middle of his garage.
Related: Rapper Arrested for Alleged Financial Crimes
Cutting the Garage in Half
A second surveyor confirmed the finding, and by Memorial Day the complaining neighbor seemed to accept it. He asked if he could go into the part of the garage that sat over the line to retrieve his father’s ashes. The family said yes. Then, according to them, he started throwing trash around, smashing glass, and tossing bureaus into the yard.
That changed things.
The next day, Mr. Brawn took a reciprocating saw and cut down the half of the garage sitting on his family’s property, leaving the remains on the other side of the surveyor’s line. The neighbor who complained about the boundary ended up with half a garage — one that doesn’t have a back wall.
The local police chief told reporters that there had been a property-line dispute for a couple of months and that the cutting was the result of it.
He said police were aware of the situation and believed it had been resolved. No charges were filed, and no lawsuit appears to be coming.
This isn’t the first time someone has dealt with a boundary dispute by slicing a building in two.
Related: Former Comcast employee sues over pie policy
A similar case in Minnesota went to court in 2014 after a man used a chainsaw to cut through structures on his side of the line.
The plaintiff sued, claiming adverse possession or a prescriptive easement over the land under the other half of the garage. He lost at trial, and the Minnesota Court of Appeals affirmed the decision in 2016.
What stands out in both cases is that the people doing the cutting had the property line professionally verified first. The Maine surveyors confirmed the boundary before any damage was done.
That’s probably the real lesson here — if you’re going to make a stand about where your land ends, it helps to know exactly where that line actually is.
Whether the half-garage owner in Maine plans any legal action remains unclear. For now, the police consider the matter closed, and the family has its wood chips and its side of the boundary line back.
The neighbor has a garage that’s no longer structurally sound, along with what’s likely a lasting reminder that property disputes can get messy when someone decides to test the limits of the law.
