There is nothing special about April Fools’ Day for the legal system, because the news cycle rarely stops being absurd. In a sense, every day functions like April Fools’ Day here. Take the recent court filings in Newport Beach, California, where two Gypsy clans are in dispute over control of the local fortunetelling business. Or the lawsuit in Louisiana where a woman claims she was injured when a pet nutria named Norman scared her into running over her own foot with a shopping cart. These events, and others like them, suggest that truth is often stranger than fiction, even when the fiction is a deliberate prank.
A closer look at recent legal filings reveals a collection of cases that defy easy categorization. One witness, testifying in a deposition, claims that “alienlike creatures emerge from his closet and put pinholes into his chest and those of his family members.” The district attorney stands by this testimony, asserting that there is video evidence of this “phenomenon.” Elsewhere, a woman has sued over a pair of defective clown shoes. An inmate is suing prison officials after sustaining injuries during an escape attempt, alleging negligence because officials knew of his history of trying to flee but failed to stop him.
Related: Lawyer laments loss after being punched in nose
The rhetoric in the courtroom can be equally baffling. In one case, a closing argument began with the chilling statement, “Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I’ll kill all of you if you find me guilty.” Legal arguments have even cited the blog Lowering the Bar as authority in a brief to the Supreme Court of the Philippines. Then there is the case entitled United States v. 50,000 Cardboard Boxes, More or Less, Each Containing One Pair of Clacker Balls.
Tennessee authorities recently highlighted a case involving a former beauty queen who stalked, kidnapped, and sexually assaulted a Mormon missionary. She jumped bail by disguising herself as a member of a deaf-mute theater troupe. Decades later, she surfaced in South Korea surrounded by the world’s first cloned pit-bull puppies. The report adds that she was also wanted in Tennessee for conspiring to steal money needed to buy an artificial limb for a three-legged horse. It is difficult to imagine a more improbable real-life scenario than this one.
Related: Cardiologist in Las Vegas and the Reality of Cardiovascular Care
The Charlotte Observer recently published a story about a new fashion trend allegedly developed in opposition to “sagging.” This trend, called “hiking,” involves pulling pants upward. The report notes that the writer covered this topic just yesterday. The observer suggests that while sagging pants might make it easier for people to flee from police, the “hiking” trend is arguably more disturbing for society. It is a debate over which sartorial choice presents a greater threat to public order.
While the list of bizarre lawsuits and court cases might seem like a collection of jokes, they are all documented facts. The reality of the legal system is that it often mirrors the chaos of a comedy sketch. When people look at these events, they often wonder how such things can be real. The answer is simply that they are, and there is no need to wait until April first to find them.
